Contracts are drawn up beforehand, travel is part-funded by the EU , everything is above board, and so far every migrant has gone back as agreed. As a result, 10, Moroccan workers did not have to run the risk of taking a patera across the Strait of Gibraltar. They were able to send remittances home but put no strain on Spain's public services. Mr Frattini wants to launch another pilot programme in his native Italy, where southern farmers might recruit workers from Egypt or Tunisia. Moldova and Ukraine want to get involved in similar schemes.
If the projects work one in Corsica was less successful , Mr Frattini would like to scale them up, with member countries eventually setting import quotas for foreign labour. The EU is planning to establish job centres in north Africa, beginning with one in Mali, to offer a legal route to jobs in Europe, and also provide some language training.
But this part of what Mr Frattini and others call circular migration has been tried before and seems unlikely to bring the hoped-for benefits. Germany's Gastarbeiter scheme began in , drawing workers first from southern Europe and north Africa and then Turkey. Something similar was done in France and the Netherlands, mostly with workers from north Africa. America imported Mexican farm labourers under its Bracero programme.
The trouble is that such a dirigiste design is not well suited to today's liberal democracies and their flexible labour markets. And unless schemes are tightly regulated and the exit of workers is enforced by law, everybody has an interest in keeping the supposedly termporary workers in place. Employers would much prefer not to have to train new people every six months, and workers want to keep their jobs or move on to better ones. Many of the guest workers who arrived in northern Europe from Turkey and north Africa in the s and s never left, and eventually brought their families to live with them too.
Democracy in America | The Economist
The old joke that there is nothing so permanent as a temporary migrant has more than a grain of truth in it. It might be possible to create financial incentives for migrants to leave at the end of their contract period.
- Modern Islamic Political Thought!
- An Introduction to Behavioral Economics.
- The Economics Daily.
- Stealing the Mystic Lamb: The True Story of the Worlds Most Coveted Masterpiece.
Co-operation between the governments of the host and the sending countries would be essential, says Mr Frattini. And migrants could be policed more tightly with the aid of new technology: ID cards, databases with biometric details, systems like E -verify in America that allow employers to check whether workers are authorised to be in the country. Proponents of circular migration admit that it would entail a loss of privacy. The biggest problem, though, is that people who expect to be packed off home after six months will be seen as second-class residents, and will have less incentive to integrate with their hosts.
Why learn the language or adopt local habits and values for just a few months? Locals, for their part, are likely to view temporary labourers with the same sort of hostility as longer-term immigrants. When migration is made legal and easy, many migrants choose to go home after a year or two. This is already a well-established habit in rich countries. Growing numbers of wealthy Germans, Britons or Nordics spend parts of the year somewhere sunny and then go home again. Perhaps more of this sort of movement could be encouraged, with rich countries offering workers multi-entry visas valid for several years at a time.
Yet any sort of circular migration brings challenges of integration. Faster movements of people, combined with technology—cable television piping entertainment from the sending country, cheap phone and video calls back home—slow the rate at which migrants adopt their host country's language, values and identity. In the past a third-generation migrant, for example in America, would have been expected to have shed much of his grandparents' identity.
Academics reckoned that a second-generation migrant would be fluent in his host country's language but would use his mother tongue at home. By the third generation descendents of migrants had usually swapped to English alone. Have they? Bagehot: Kindergarten cabinet. Banks and bonuses: Ker-ching.
Site Information Navigation
Reforming the police: Boys in blue head into the red. Medical care: Paying a deadly price. The markets: Flashing red. Above the fold.
Medieval ivories: Pause as you pass. Emerging-market multinationals: The challengers. The music industry: From major to minor. Last year was terrible for the recorded-music majors. The next few years are likely to be even worse. The London mayoral race: Political capital. Benazir Bhutto.
Benazir Bhutto, Pakistani politician, was killed on December 27th, aged Commercial property: Dominoes on the skyline. Global warming : Much talk, and a little action, at the UN climate summit. International 2 hrs 6 mins ago. The Ukrainian connection : How close does the Ukraine scandal bring Donald United States September 23rd, Streaming consciousness : The Emmys reveal a fragmented television Prospero September 23rd, Daily chart : Do congressional retirements help predict American election Graphic detail September 23rd, Business and finance September 23rd, Want more from The Economist?
Sponsored by:. Henry Kissinger: Ideas man Oct 1st , from Print edition. Geopolitics: A bit of a mess Sep 4th , from Print edition. The birth of Bangladesh: Blood meridian Sep 19th , from Print edition.
Nuclear disarmament: Move the base camp Jun 16th , from Print edition. America and China: No go May 19th , from Print edition. Trade and conserve May 20th , from Print edition. Henry Kissinger in A year to remember Jul 9th , from Print edition. Omission: impossible Nov 14th , from Democracy in America.
America and China: Grand vision and petty deceit Oct 26th , from Print edition. Obituary: Richard Avedon Oct 7th , from Print edition. Sep 30th , from Print edition. The Vietnam war: Getting out is never easy Feb 27th , from Print edition. Warmakers 2: Right to the end Oct 22nd , from Print edition. Jul 19th , from Print edition. How to be Number One Jul 5th , from Print edition. Washington vendettas: Oh, Henry Apr 19th , from Print edition. Vietnam war: Unsparing Nov 30th , from Print edition. Sep 16th , from Print edition.
America and China: Harder than it looks May 20th , from Print edition. Subscribe to this topic. Follow The Economist.